Current:Home > StocksHow Do Neighbors of Solar Farms Really Feel? A New Survey Has Answers-LoTradeCoin
How Do Neighbors of Solar Farms Really Feel? A New Survey Has Answers
View Date:2024-12-23 20:41:27
For people living within three miles of a large solar farm, positive attitudes about the development outnumber negative ones by about a three-to-one margin, according to a new national survey released this week by Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory.
Some of the results are likely to be encouraging for solar developers, and could be used in local debates to show that community sentiment may favor solar more than is evident just from looking at often-contentious testimony at local public hearings.
But solar opponents also can point to parts of the report that show serious concerns about development. For example, the survey found that people who live within three miles of projects that are 100 megawatts or larger have negative attitudes that outnumber positive ones by about 12 to one.
We’re hiring!
Please take a look at the new openings in our newsroom.
See jobsIn other words, positive sentiment is largely coming from people near smaller projects.
“We’re finding that size matters,” said Sarah Mills, a University of Michigan professor who was part of the team behind the survey. “Bigger is not always better.”
The results are notable at a time when proposals for solar farms often face substantial local opposition. This resistance, seen mainly in rural areas, is a major problem considering that the country needs to vastly expand its use of renewable energy to make a transition away from fossil fuels.
The report is one of the first to look at community attitudes since the boom in solar development of the last few years. It also uses a national sample as opposed to focusing on individual states or regions.
A team that included researchers from Lawrence Berkeley, the University of Michigan and Michigan State University conducted the survey in 2023. The responses came from 984 people in 39 states who live near solar projects built between 2017 to 2021. The projects range in size from 1 megawatt to 252 megawatts.
Among the other findings:
- Fewer than one-fifth of respondents were aware of a solar project before construction began. This indicates that processes for giving notice to people who live near projects are not working.
- The most trusted sources of information are people who live near existing solar projects, community organizations and university staff. The least trusted are solar developers and government officials.
- There was strong support for building solar on disturbed sites such as landfills and former industrial land, and much less support for building solar on areas that are forested or used for farming.
One researcher who was not involved in the survey said the report has left him asking questions that still need answers.
“The fact that [Lawrence Berkeley] is probing the reactions of people living near large solar facilities is great,” said Larry Susskind, a professor of urban and environmental planning at MIT and vice chair of the program on negotiation at Harvard Law School, in an email. “But emphasizing only positive or negative attitudes doesn’t tell us much about what aspects of facility siting create difficulties and unfairness for specific groups. Unless you dig in and cross-tabulate who has what specific reasons for being positive or negative with their income, location, home ownership and other demographic variables, you don’t really learn much that can help public policy-makers, community activists or public officials improve the siting process.”
He and his team at MIT have written extensively about the conflicts that arise around renewable energy developments.
Based on this work as a mediator in such conflicts, he has found that vocal opposition from as little as 15 percent to 25 percent of a community will likely lead elected officials and much of the rest of the community to support their unhappy neighbors, even if many people in the community support solar development as a way to fight climate change.
His point, as it relates to the Lawrence Berkeley survey, is that majority support for solar may not be enough in the face of a motivated minority.
Co-authors of the report said there is still much to learn about what motivates people to support or oppose a local project, and this survey is one part of a larger, long-term effort to improve the level of understanding.
The report is the first of what are likely to be several releases of findings from the survey, likely containing some of the information Susskind is seeking.
Karl Hoesch, a Ph.D. student at the University of Michigan and a co-author of the report, cautioned against using the survey results to make broad statements about whether people support or oppose solar.
“There’s just a lot of nuance there,” he said. “Even within those contexts where there is a lot of opposition, there are also neighbors that maybe aren’t showing up to those meetings, and maybe are quietly positive” toward solar development.
Share this article
veryGood! (9424)
Related
- Singles' Day vs. Black Friday: Which Has the Best Deals for Smart Shoppers?
- Caitlin Clark sets record for most assists in a WNBA game: Fever vs. Wings stats
- Stegosaurus named Apex goes for $44.6M at auction, most expensive fossil ever sold
- Kim Kardashian Details Horrible Accident That Left Her With Broken Fingers
- Who is Rep. Matt Gaetz, the Florida congressman Donald Trump picked to serve as attorney general?
- More Americans apply for jobless benefits as layoffs settle at higher levels in recent weeks
- The challenges of navigating an unrelenting news cycle
- Caitlin Clark has 19 assists break WNBA record in Fever’s 101-93 loss to Wings
- Gerry Faust, former Notre Dame football coach, dies at 89
- Alabama set to execute man for fatal shooting of a delivery driver during a 1998 robbery attempt
Ranking
- Jason Kelce Jokes He Got “Mixed Reviews” From Kylie Kelce Over NSFW Commentary
- Off the Grid: Sally breaks down USA TODAY's daily crossword puzzle, Tri-Tip
- Kenney Grant, founder of iconic West Virginia pizza chain Gino’s, dies
- The Grateful Dead and Francis Ford Coppola are among the newest Kennedy Center Honors recipients
- Mandy Moore Captures the Holiday Vibe With These No Brainer Gifts & Stocking Stuffer Must-Haves
- The Vampire Diaries' Torrey DeVitto Says She Quit Show Due to Paul Wesley Divorce
- Florida teenager survives 'instantaneous' lightning strike: Reports
- Greenhouses are becoming more popular, but there’s little research on how to protect workers
Recommendation
-
Question of a lifetime: Families prepare to confront 9/11 masterminds
-
Powerball winning numbers for July 17 drawing: Jackpot at $75 million
-
Montana judge: Signatures of inactive voters count for initiatives, including 1 to protect abortion
-
Last Call for Prime Day 2024: The Top 37 Last-Minute Deals You Should Add to Your Cart Now
-
In bizarro world, Tennessee plays better defense, and Georgia's Kirby Smart comes unglued
-
Sheryl Lee Ralph overjoyed by Emmy Awards nomination: 'Never gets old'
-
Hundreds attend vigil for man killed at Trump rally in Pennsylvania before visitation Thursday
-
Lucas Turner: Should you time the stock market?